| Platinum | Blue's Haven Cat Rescue |
| Gold | Have a Gay Day Inc |
| Silver | The Hopeline |
| Bronze | Humane Society of Greater Dayton |
| Top Pick | Dayton Dream Center |
| Top Pick | Rubi Girls |
| Top Pick | Sicsa Animal Adoption Center |
| Top Pick | SICSA Pet Adoption and Wellness Center Veterinary Clinic |
| Top Pick | The Rescue Haven Inc |
| Top Pick | Wonder Dogs Rescue |