| Platinum | Dayton Humane & Co |
| Gold | Rustic & Rooted |
| Silver | Meowza Cat Boutique |
| Bronze | Zig Zag Gallery |
| Top Pick | Buckeye Charm |
| Top Pick | Lula Bell Whimsical Cards & Gifts |
| Top Pick | M & Company |
| Top Pick | Palette of Threads |
| Top Pick | The Style In You Collection |
| Top Pick | With Much Grace Boutique |