| Platinum | Joe's Pizzeria |
| Gold | Marion's Piazza |
| Silver | Pizza Factory |
| Bronze | Cassano's Pizza King |
| Top Pick | Dewey's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Gionino's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Old Scratch Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pies & Pints |
| Top Pick | Rooster's Wings |
| Top Pick | Wheat Penny Oven and Bar |