| Platinum | The Spaghetti Warehouse |
| Gold | Mamma Disalvo's Italian Ristorante |
| Silver | Jimmy's Italian Kitchen |
| Bronze | Demnika's Italian Restuarant |
| Top Pick | Bravo! Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Flying Pizza |
| Top Pick | Larosa's Pizza Kettering |
| Top Pick | Napoli's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Tony's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Wheat Penny Oven and Bar |