| Platinum | 3 Dips Ice Cream Shoppe |
| Gold | Young's Jersey Dairy |
| Silver | Rip Rap Shake Shack |
| Bronze | Tom & Dots Gelato |
| Top Pick | Cold Stone Creamery |
| Top Pick | Graeter's Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Jds Frozen Custard |
| Top Pick | Ritters Frozen Custard |
| Top Pick | Super Scoops Ice Cream |
| Top Pick | Sweet Ps Handcrafted Ice Pops |