| Platinum | Charlie's Deli & Catering |
| Gold | Main Street Deli |
| Silver | Dorothy Lane Market |
| Bronze | Mamma Disalvo's Italian Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Bullpen |
| Top Pick | Carmen's Deli |
| Top Pick | Jersey Mike's Subs |
| Top Pick | McAlister's Deli |
| Top Pick | Tom & Dots Gelato |
| Top Pick | Tony & Pete's |