| Platinum | Grab Da Cookies |
| Gold | Insomnia Cookie |
| Silver | Crumbl Cookies - Washington Township |
| Bronze | Ashley's Pastry Shop |
| Top Pick | Anchored Baking Co |
| Top Pick | Cake Hope and Love |
| Top Pick | Cheryl & Co |
| Top Pick | Great American Cookies |
| Top Pick | Mehaffies Pies |
| Top Pick | Sinfully Gluten Free |